Maokun (post: 1330367) wrote:Bad: Love Hina! Ken Akamatsu's mangas are your typical fanservice-y harem stories, but I personally believe he has a good narrative and a great balance of drama and comedy. The gorgeous character design is just the cherry ontop. The anime shed most of the drama, mangled the character design and left only an empty, poorly-animated husk of silly humour and fanservice.
Maokun (post: 1330367) wrote:Bad: One Piece. This is totally subjective, but I feel the rather particular character design of Eichiro Oda does not work that well in the screen. The series is still amazing because it's quite faithful to the manga, but I much rather have the painstalkely detailed panels of the original manga than the cartoony animation of the series.
ShiroiHikari (post: 1330358) wrote:I know nobody else feels the same way as I do on this one, but I thought the Full Moon wo Sagashite anime was not a good adaptation. You don't stretch a 7-volume manga into 50 episodes. It just doesn't work.
KhakiBlueSocks wrote:"I'm going to make you a prayer request you can't refuse..." Cue the violins.
I'd argue that the broadcast order only works because of the particular chapters they decided to adapt. In a world where Kyoto didn't go insane and decided to produce the second season normally, the chronological order would work just as well, since the climax of the show (Disappearance) would be in the right spot.
Return to Anime and Anime Reviews
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 337 guests