TheSubtleDoctor (post: 1372933) wrote:Completed Fullmetal Alchemist.
No words for it at the minute. Immediately watching FMA Brotherhood 1.
*Edit: NOOO!!! They changed the voice actor for Mustang-san!!!! Agh!
*cursing while clicking back on the video window*
TheSubtleDoctor (post: 1372933) wrote:Completed Fullmetal Alchemist.
No words for it at the minute. Immediately watching FMA Brotherhood 1.
*Edit: NOOO!!! They changed the voice actor for Mustang-san!!!! Agh!
*cursing while clicking back on the video window*
TheSubtleDoctor (post: 1371562) wrote:OK, you are really making me want to watch that show. "HR with guns" is a truly intriguing description. The ethical angle sound pretty cool as well.
Just provoking me to think is a plus, so I will give GG a go, but it has been pushed onto the back burner due to the amazingness of FMA. I simply HAVE to watch more of Brotherhood. Yeah, Mustang's VA in the first series was unbelievable. He pulled off all the the various facets of the character: the smugness, the effortless charm, the steely determination, the vulnerable moments...You said it, Okawa-san is Mustang.the_wolfs_howl (post: 1373037) wrote:Go for it! But just to make sure you understand, they raise the ethical questions, but don't really answer them. Which is fine, if you ask me.
And I completely agree with you about the first FMA series]how[/i] I'm going to survive until the March chapter of the manga comes out And I, too, was disappointed in the change of Mustang's seiyuu, because for me Toru Okawa was Mustang. He takes a few episodes to really get the hang of Mustang's character, I felt, but he's actually a really good voice for him, I think.
Chill, sir. I will get used to it (by the end of the first episode it was beginning to sound normal to me), but I am just taking a moment to mourn. The change was so jarring, since ALL the other VAs seemed the same to me. And while the original content was not as good as the first half of the show, it was by no means a Rurouni Kenshin situation. So, all things considered, I liked the original content; however, I am even more jazzed about finding out where the story truly goes after ep 25. I trust your opinions, so if you think it is better than the best of the first series...just, wow. So jazzed!blkmage (post: 1372941) wrote:Honestly, suck it up. We all got used to it, so can you. If you liked the first FMA, then Brotherhood will be that minus the awful original content plus the awesome manga content that no one thought would be animated. Since the current arc started, it has blown away the best of the first anime (as opposed to matching), and as a manga reader, I can say with certainty that it only gets better.
As for all this FullMetal Alchemist talk going around, let me just say that Brotherhood trades in marginalized-side-character Anime King Bradley for not-watered-down-totally-awesome Manga King Bradley, which means that it is fundamentally better than the original series.
TheSubtleDoctor (post: 1373174) wrote:Just finished FMA Brothehood 5. Not sure if this is actually a spoiler but just to be safe[spoiler]Does the whole show feel this rushed, or is the director just plowing through the old stuff as fast as he can? I am a fan of some of Brotherhood's additions (Ed's time at the gate in ep 2, and some of the Homunculus scenes, just to name a couple), but some scenes from these episodes lack the power of their corresponding scenes from the first series, specifically Basque Grand's death and the results of Tucker's experiment with Nina. Both of these moments had more gravity, IMO, in the original.[/spoiler]
blkmage (post: 1373175) wrote:Yes. It is definitely quicker paced, but some of the effect may be because we've seen it already so we know what's going to happen. However, in terms of placement in the story, certain things happen much, much earlier on and certain characters had their importance inflated in the first anime. Don't be surprised when some people bite it relatively early on.
TheSubtleDoctor (post: 1373833) wrote:FMA Brotherhood up through 18. I now have mad respect for Col. Mustang. Always liked his character, but his talent for deception/manipulation (which was only hinted at in the first series) is a site to behold.[spoiler]I thought he actually killed Lt. Ross, so ep 18 was pretty surprising.[/spoiler]Mustang possesses a lot of the qualities I like about Griffith from Bersek without dipping into the latter's more sinister side (yet).
I am totally digging Brotherhood since it has emerged from the (partial) retread episodes.
ST. Attidude (post: 1374926) wrote:I finished ep. 18 of My Bride is a Mermaid and all I can say is "Holy Crud!" XD
Return to Anime and Anime Reviews
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 130 guests