USSRGirl wrote: Just saying... it's important to discern what is a message from God and what's an experience based on human emotion.
USSRGirl wrote:Tenshi, what tongue are you speaking in? In the Bible, when the disciples spoke in tongues it was in the various languages of the people around them (Greek, Hebrew, Aramaic, ect....) so that everyone present could hear and understand the gospel. I really don't mean to sound like jerk about this since it was your experience and not mine, but tongues in the Bible were not just nonsense syllables, "spirit language", or something created by an emotional high. Just saying... it's important to discern what is a message from God and what's an experience based on human emotion.
USSRGirl wrote: Hmmm.... well I'll pray that God reveals His will to you. It might help if you knew what language it resembled (Japanese maybe you said? If you know someone who speaks Japanese you could try sounding it out to them and see if it rings any bells). I don't remember anywhere in the Bible where tongues were used as a communication between you and God. Everytime God communicated with someone it was in an understandable language (makes sense to me since He'd kinda want you to know what He was saying ]
Ah I just said japanese because that's phonetically what I usually relate words too^^
True that there's no Biblical reference on it, but there are things such as "slain in the spirit" which occur, but no actual reference to it. I just know that in private I'm able to have this ability/gift and have heard of others that can too. Heck, I heard of a speaker that considered it his second language, but I'll get into that in a second...USSRGirl wrote:
As to why the person next to you was saying the exact same thing... where was this? In a church? Sorry to be a skeptic here, but in churches I've known that "teach" people to speak in tongues most people in the congregation end up repeating the same thing whether consciously immitating one another or just doing it as they were taught by the pastor. Again, I have no idea if your church is like that or what the experience was like for you. I just think it's important to discern a spiritual experience from a human one taught by man or brought on by an emotional experience.
USSRGirl wrote:Also, did anyone "teach" you how to speak in tongues? Reason I'm this is because I heard from someone who talked with a pastor who "spoke in tongues." When he asked the pastor how he did it, the pastor instructed him to "let go", get himself into a serene state of emotion, and basically just babble like an idiot in no particular language. O.o]
Oooh I see what you mean now... No, no one ever "taught" me how to do it. Although, the speaker did encourage it thoroughly, saying "sometimes it's like a small child who cannot speak: you can babble at first but then it will turn into words. Just... give it a shot!" sort of thing. As for me, it can be a slight babble/tongue-twist at first, because I'm already praying (in enlgish) outloud and things get a bit fused and mixed up, but eventually comes out clear. I don't try and push it though (although it is an interesting experience), if it comes it comes.USSRGirl wrote:As for the pastor who considered tongues his "second language" I have to say that sounds an awful lot like a charismatic stage show type of thing. Getting yourself pumped up to an emotional high where you can babble things isn't a God experience. Neither is memorizing some Greek and Hebrew (which is required language course for most seminary students) as a crowd pleaser. Reason being, next to no one speaks Greek or Hebrew nowadays. Chinese yeah maybe, but breaking off into Chinese in between Greek, Hebrew, and English is not going to make the gospel any more clear to the few Chinese folks sitting in church. In Acts it seemed to imply that each disciple was hit by the spirit and started speaking one tongue for the bennefit of that group of people, while another guy might be speaking another tongue. If the pastor's tongues was a personal experience with God, then it doesn't need to be coincidently displayed on Sunday morning. The Bible not to be like the pagans or Pharisees when we pray - walking down the street with hands clasped in prayer, repeating things we don't understand just to look holy, ect. So I'd be pretty skeptical there.
Mave wrote:I'm sorry to say that events like this scare off my non-believing friends. I'm also sorry to say that as a Christian, I totally steer clear of this session.
In one of my previous churches, I was pressured to receive the gift of tongues because there was this belief that if you don't have the gift, you haven't tried hard enough or your faith is not strong. I shouldn't have believed it because it made me a miserable Christian.
Tenshi no Ai wrote:Oh wow, really? Did they... not realize that everyone is different and gifts vary from person to person?^^
On the scare off issue, do you mean tongues in general? It is an... odd thing and I was freaked out my first few times going to a protestant church and people were shouting loud things and falling on the floor twitching slightly^^ Yeah... some experience they were^^ Of course, spiritual gifts, happenings etc sure aren't what Christianity is about. We're not about "watch these miracles happen! We're awsome!", heck no :/ It's not... like that :/
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 236 guests